XO INVESTMENTS’ services for private clients range from wealth management to pension advice.
The deterioration in public finances is the focus of much of the concern, but it is merely the most visible part of a deeper dilemma: how can the deficit be reduced sustainably without further weakening an already fragile economy? An adjustment that is too abrupt would weigh on demand, investment and employment; one that is too slow would prolong the rise in debt and limit the government’s scope for action.
The current economic climate makes this a particularly tricky situation. After stagnating in the second quarter, French GDP fell by 0.1 per cent in the third quarter. France therefore finds itself on the cusp between stagnation and recession, although it is not yet possible to speak of a genuine, sustained contraction in economic activity.
At the same time, the traditional drivers of demand are showing signs of weakness. Consumer spending is being hit by declining household confidence, which is encouraging a cautious approach. Investment, for its part, is suffering from economic, political and fiscal uncertainties: businesses are delaying certain decisions, which is weighing not only on current economic activity but also on future productive capacity.
The labour market is another area of concern. Private-sector employment has fallen year-on-year, and unemployment stood at 8.3 per cent in the second quarter. There is a risk of a vicious circle: weaker growth hampers employment, erodes confidence and consumption, and ultimately reduces public revenue at the very moment when fiscal consolidation is becoming more urgent.
France’s problems therefore extend far beyond the issue of debt. High debt remains sustainable when the economy generates sufficient growth and productivity gains. However, the scope for action is limited when high debt, weak growth and inelastic expenditure combine.
Yet there is no shortage of structural pressures: an ageing population, healthcare, the energy transition and defence will limit the scope for a painless fiscal adjustment. Recovery cannot therefore rely solely on tax increases or across-the-board spending cuts. The challenge lies more in improving the efficiency of public spending whilst preserving the expenditure that supports investment and future growth.
France nevertheless retains recognised expertise in high value-added sectors, notably aerospace, luxury goods, defence and energy. These centres of excellence are reflected in the composition of the CAC 40, as illustrated in the table below. These industries can also draw on high-quality infrastructure, a strong research base and largely decarbonised electricity generation. These strengths provide a solid foundation for supporting investment and reindustrialisation.
The contrast between the fragility of the French economy and the resilience of its stock market is striking. Despite the economic climate, the French stock market index rose by 80 per cent (dividends reinvested) between 2021 and August 2026. It is only in recent months that the CAC 40 has fallen.
This stock market resilience is largely due to the highly international nature of the major listed companies. The stock market index remains heavily exposed to global sectors such as industry, energy, aerospace, defence, technology and luxury goods, and is therefore more dependent on the global economic cycle than on French demand alone.
In 2026, however, sectoral trends are very mixed: energy, aerospace and defence, certain industrial sectors and semiconductors are holding up better, whilst the luxury goods and automotive sectors remain under greater pressure due to the global context. This situation highlights a key distinction: a struggling French economy does not necessarily mean that French companies are struggling, particularly when their markets, revenues and growth prospects lie largely outside France.
France therefore faces a delicate balancing act: it must spend less where expenditure is unproductive, safeguard investment – which is a prerequisite for future growth – and restore sufficient confidence so that households and businesses can start spending and investing again.
Debt is often presented as the root of France’s problems. In reality, it is more a symptom of them. Debt is, in fact, an accumulation fuelled by a stream of deficits. As long as these remain high, each financial year adds a new layer to the existing debt burden.
The causes of the deficit are manifold and not all of them lie within the government’s control. For this reason, economists distinguish between the ‘total balance’ (or deficit) and the ‘primary balance’. The latter measures the budget balance before interest payments, and can be directly influenced by fiscal policies: expansionary policies (more government spending, lower taxes) result in an increase in the primary balance, and the reverse is true for restrictive policies.
To stabilise its debt, a country must therefore first stabilise its primary balance. However, France’s public debt, at nearly 120 per cent of GDP, increases the sensitivity of public finances to interest rates and makes interest payments a significant factor. During periods of rising interest rates, investors tend to focus on interest payments. This dynamic ultimately undermines the credibility of the entire fiscal policy.
For a decade, France benefited from exceptionally favourable financing conditions, which made it possible to keep the interest burden in check despite rising debt. That period is now over. At the end of September 2026, the weighted average rate on debt issued since the start of the year stood at 3.55 per cent. As the average maturity of marketable debt remains above eight years, the rise in interest rates is gradually being passed on to the budget as older bonds mature and are refinanced.
Refinancing is thus becoming a key factor in the equation. The government must finance both new deficits and maturing debt. For 2026, France’s medium- and long-term issuance programme stands at around €310 billion, net of redemptions. A large proportion of this does not constitute new debt, but replaces maturing securities. The country’s refinancing needs will remain high in the coming years: half of the existing debt will mature over the next five years! The cost of debt will rise rapidly if interest rates remain at current levels.
The budgetary implications are significant, as interest payments reduce the resources available for education, infrastructure, defence, innovation and the energy transition. The government will therefore face a choice between running an even larger deficit to safeguard future growth, or reducing the deficit and jeopardising future growth.
The markets are well aware of this situation and are anticipating what may happen in the coming six-month periods. The yield spread between German and French bonds has widened significantly in recent weeks. This reflects the markets’ mistrust of France’s fiscal situation.
The key challenge for France is therefore to curb the rise in the deficit without stifling growth, as, in the long run, the sustainability of the debt will depend just as much on the ability to control spending as on the ability to restore growth.
“France is doing better. Not better than last year. But better than next year.”
Coluche